American Idol Reinstatement
According to these fans a third party Facebook page played the culprit by showing the mislabeled voting phone umbers for Aaron Kelly. They plea that it is the only reason that Siobhan Magnus was in the bottom three and not Aaron Kelly as expected by many.
Results? The fervent fans have developed an online petition that bears around 4000 digital signatures. The fans have threatened of never watching American Idol again if their petition is gone unheard.
Well, we have not enough background knowledge to comment on the petition or Siobhan Magnus’s fate at American Idol, but we assure our readers that Siobhan Magnus is surely a part of American Idol Live 2010 tour along with top 10 finalists of the show in current season.
The leaving of Siobhan Magnus earlier than Aaron Kelly on Wednesday night was really shocking but it was all like that as Aaron grabbed sympathy votes, Magnus was not lucky enough to impress Simon with her screaming who termed it of a woman in child labor.
Well, fans and not so fans (like me) of Siobhan Magnus would wait for the next episode to learn what comes out of this on line petition. Do we see an American Idol Reinstatement?
Siobhan Magnus
what is website address for American Idol Reinstatement campaign?
Why did you make it seem like Siobhan did not impress Simon in her last performance?! She did impress him! He told her that it was good and fun and that he liked her song choice a lot. The only negative talking he did about it was about the scream and thats when he compared it to a women giving birth. He was impressed with everything else in her performance though. So say it right!
Good intentions here but if you really think an internet petition is going to get Siobhan Magnus back on Idol you will be greatly dissappointed.
Hope she will be reinstated, sounds like a whopper of an error was made, if so it should definitely be
investigated, like so many, American Idol reputation is at stake here, they better take heed………
Suck it up…she got eliminated!!! I say it’s about time. She figured out early in the competition that she could belt out one big note and impress the fans….and that is ALL she did after that. Not one show passed that she didn’t open that big mouth and scream…thinking of course that because she had hit that big note before that she needed to ride that ONE talent as long as she could. I think Simon was absolutely correct that she was screaming (not singing) and she DID in fact sound like a woman in labor. And another thing that irritated me about her….she couldn’t just LISTEN to the judges, she always had to make a comment back at them….trying to justify whatever part of her performance they were addressing….can you say SHUT UP and listen to what they are saying???? Not everything requires a response. I’m guessing that there is way more than 4000 people who would be more than willing to sign a petition to keep her gone.
its sweet that siobhans fans are tryin to get her back on the show but I really dont think idol will let her back on. besides had she survived this week she would of maybe be on the show 1 or 2 more weeks anyways. So yes she should of made it longer than Aaron on the show but I really doubt she would of won had she still been on the show. Plus I think if her fans and others are so upset that she was voted off too soon then what they need to do is support her on tour, buy her albums n singles when they come out and help her gain new non-idol fans. So that she becomes one of the best selling of this seasons group.
Where can I find the site. I definately want to sign it. I WON’T watch American Idol ever again…it is all politics…too bad us 60 oiver group really enjoyed this talented lady.
Hmmm, 4000 fans out the millions that watch American Idol may not tune in again — can’t see the network getting too excited about that! Gonna need a lot more signatures. But let’s face facts, whether reinstated or not, Siobhan is not going to the “The Next American Idol”. At best, she’ll get another show or two, and then leave (again). Hey, I like Siobhan – always have, but she’s not up to the level of Lee or Crystal. Let it go.
Every year, someone, somewhere, claims the exact same thing…..their personal favorite was booted off due to a “voting glitch”. Too bad no one has ever been able to prove it. Siobhan was awful, just plain awful, and deserved to go.
Wonder who “votefortheworst” is backing now that she is gone.
Just my two cents…………….oh and internet petitions aren’t worth the electricity it takes to find the website and sign up. They are worthless.